The City of Miami Springs collects thousands of dollars from the red light cameras (mostly along NW 36th street) and its recently introduced speed trap cameras at local school zones.

However, a recent article published by Yahoo!News discovers a potential monkey wrench in this revenue stream.

Surveillance Camera on Fairway Drive and Palmetto Drive (Automated License Plate Reader)
Surveillance Camera on Fairway Drive and Palmetto Drive (Automated License Plate Reader)

According to the article, a Broward County judge “dismissed a red-light camera ticket and ruled that key parts of the state’s law may violate constitutional due process protections.”

Automated License Plate Reader (ALPR) located at Curtiss Parkway and Canal Street in Miami Springs
Automated License Plate Reader (ALPR) located at Curtiss Parkway and Canal Street in Miami Springs

The crux of the matter is this:  Can the government find a specific individual in violation of a traffic law if you’re not certain who was driving the vehicle?  The cameras can film the car running the red light.  The cameras can identify the vehicle that ran the red light.  The data can tell us who is the registrant of vehicle that was caught on camera violating a traffic law.

Surveillance Camera at East Drive and South Royal Poinciana Boulevard (Automated License Plate Reader)

But can the camera identify WHO was driving the vehicle at the time of the recorded violation?

Surveillance Camera on North Royal Poinciana Blvd and Ludlam (Automated License Plate Reader)

Is the vehicle registrant responsible for traffic violations committed by others?

Speed Limit Photo Enforced

What do you think?  Should the government have to prove WHO was driving the vehicle when the infraction was caught on camera?  Let us know your thoughts in the comments section or via social media.

 

 

Hole 19
The Leonard Real Estate Group
Coastal Insurance Group
Miami Tax Expert
Concepcion Law Criminal Defense, Personal Injury

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here